French Article

Between algorithmic opacity, the relentless race for engagement and the standardisation of content, cultural media outlets now find themselves playing by the rules of a platform that never promised to champion artistic diversity, let alone art itself. Let me ask my fellow music and culture journalists a question, without naming names (especially the biggest players among us): isn’t it all getting a bit exhausting? Let’s start by acknowledging the sheer absurdity of editorial work in the age of Instagram.

The Tyranny of Engagement

Editorial work isn’t as simple as people might think. First, you need ideas. Lots of ideas. Endless ideas. All the time. But coming up with interesting stories isn’t enough. What fascinates us won’t necessarily interest the person next door, or even the audiences we’re trying to reach. All while trying to stay true to our editorial line, give meaning to the angles and subjects we choose, and constantly ask ourselves: why this story, right now, rather than another?

And then there’s the paradox: an investigation that takes hours of research, or an in-depth feature, might struggle to find its audience, while a fifteen-second video designed to grab attention can rack up thousands of views. Written formats, in particular, struggle to find their place in this battle for attention, even though, alongside video reporting, they remain among the best ways to explore a subject in depth, provide context and encourage reflection.

Generally speaking, long-form content is at a disadvantage. We know that. What a nightmare for those of us who are used to being anything but concise (or maybe that’s just me). Isn’t education part of the very essence of working in culture? Entertaining people, yes, but educating them too. Of course, it’s up to us, as journalists and cultural professionals, to adapt, to find better ways of communicating, to learn how to be concise and make complex subjects accessible. Because yes, the audience is king.

That being said, we can still acknowledge that the quality of our work no longer guarantees its visibility. The truth is that, beyond our editorial decisions, we’re also subject to the tyranny of the algorithm. And its priorities don’t necessarily align with those of culture. Instagram doesn’t reward a piece of content for its cultural value. It rewards its ability to capture attention.

We all know this. But what does it actually mean for journalism?

Horizontal shot of serious thoughtful woman correspondent dressed in formal suit holds microphone takes interview prepares article for magazine isolated over blue background copy space for your promo

Is the Algorithm Becoming Our Editor-in-Chief?

More insidiously, the consequences of the attention economy are gradually creeping into our editorial decisions. We’re constantly analysing statistics, measuring performance and trying to figure out what will work. So how could we not start factoring those metrics into the stories we choose to cover?

We know perfectly well that a spectacular DJ set video, a story about an already-famous artist or a controversial post is more likely to circulate than an investigation into the financial struggles of independent clubs or a profile of an emerging artist.

And when time and resources are limited, the temptation to stick with what has already proven successful becomes even stronger.

This way of approaching editorial work, even unconsciously, can lead to a form of editorial self-censorship, as well as an erosion of cultural diversity. Not censorship directly imposed by Instagram, but a selection process we gradually impose on ourselves. How many ideas are abandoned before they’ve even been developed, simply because they lack viral potential?

By anticipating the expectations of an algorithm we can barely understand, we allow statistics to determine whether a piece of content deserves to exist. Thankfully, there’s still some balance. We can see it in specialist music media, and credit where credit is due to those who still take the time to produce genuinely thoughtful, high-quality and engaging content (yes, it’s possible), rather than endless street interviews with intoxicated partygoers set to a soundtrack of unbearable hard techno.

Of course, there’s also the question of sponsored content, which exists across music media outlets that have businesses to run and employees to pay. The media business model has changed, and that inevitably influences what gets published. But promotional content doesn’t automatically mean empty content. It’s our responsibility to decide who we work with, how we approach those collaborations and, above all, to be transparent about them.

The Homogenisation of Cultural Content

This issue connects to a well-documented phenomenon in research on recommendation systems: popularity bias. Certain algorithms tend to favour content that is already popular, further amplifying its visibility. It’s a mechanism reminiscent of the Matthew effect, a concept developed by sociologist Robert K. Merton.

In simple terms, those who already enjoy recognition are more likely to receive even more of it. A vicious circle.

We also know that, according to the Reuters Institute’s Digital News Report 2026, 36% of 18–24-year-olds surveyed across the markets studied say they watch news videos on Instagram every week. The platform has become an important space where younger audiences encounter information.

What gets talked about there, but also what doesn’t, deserves our attention.

In music, as in every other cultural field, there are the numbers, and then there’s a much bigger question: what kind of music culture are we choosing to put in the spotlight?There’s another issue, too. A cultural media outlet trying to share knowledge finds itself competing with political commentary, comedy, sensationalist content and everything else competing for people’s attention. Sometimes, standing out feels almost impossible.

It’s not that entertainment and culture are incompatible, quite the opposite. But does everything really have to become entertaining to deserve to be seen?

Producing Culture, Not Just Content, Should Be Our Priority If We Want to Keep It Alive <3

So yes, we need to adapt. We need to learn how to tell stories differently, experiment with new formats and find new ways to capture attention. But adapting shouldn’t mean giving up. As cultural media outlets, we also have a responsibility: not to simply reproduce what already works, but to continue championing emerging artists, exploring complex subjects and, above all, questioning trends rather than merely following them. Because our role isn’t just to entertain or generate engagement. It’s also to inform, to educate, to introduce people to new ideas and, sometimes, to challenge them!

So, to all of us working in cultural media: what are we still willing to do to keep culture alive?

SHANA BIZE